Maximizing Ethanol Production by Engineered Pentose-Fermenting Zymomonas mobilis
Maximizing Ethanol Production by Engineered Pentose-Fermenting Zymomonas mobilis
Dhinakar S. Kompala
Department of Chemical Engineering University of Colorado, Boulder
James D. McMillan and Min Zhang Biotechnology Center for Fuels and Chemicals National Renewable Energy Laboratory
Objective
Develop robust microbial biocatalysts capable of effectively conversion of a variety of sugar feedstreams to fuels (and chemicals)
Strategic Targets
• Increase Ethanol Yield • Increase Ethanol Concentration • Reduce Fermentation Time
Biomass Composition
10% Other 25% Lignin 14% Other 46% Cellulose 36% Cellulose/ 10% Lignin starch
ARABINOSE XYLOSE XYLOSE
40% Hemicellulose 19% Hemicellulose
l
Hardwood Species
l
Agricultural Residues
(i.e., Corn Fiber, Corn Stover)
Fermentation Performance Criteria Fermentation Performance Criteria
Essential Microbial Traits
l l l
High Conversion Yield High Ethanol Tolerance Resistance...
Maximizing Ethanol Production by Engineered
Pentose-Fermenting Zymomonas mobilis
Dhinakar S. Kompala
Department of Chemical Engineering
University of Colorado, Boulder
James D. McMillan and Min Zhang
Biotechnology Center for Fuels and Chemicals
National Renewable Energy Laboratory
Objective
Develop robust microbial biocatalysts
capable of effectively conversion of
a variety of sugar feedstreams
to fuels (and chemicals)
Strategic Targets
• Increase Ethanol Yield
• Increase Ethanol Concentration
• Reduce Fermentation Time
Biomass Composition
10% Other 46% Cellulose 14% Other
36% Cellulose/
25% 10% Lignin starch
Lignin
ARABINOSE
XYLOSE XYLOSE
40% Hemicellulose
19% Hemicellulose
l Hardwood Species l Agricultural Residues
(i.e., Corn Fiber, Corn Stover)
Fermentation Performance Criteria
Fermentation Performance Criteria
Desirable Traits
Essential Microbial Traits High sugar consumption rate
l High Conversion Yield High specific growth rate
High volumetric productivity
l High Ethanol Tolerance High specific productivity
l Resistance to Inhibitors in C5/C6 cofermentation
Hydrolysates Minimal nutrient requirements
High salt tolerance (acetate)
l No Oxygen Requirement
Entner-Doudoroff pathway
l Low Fermentation pH Facilitated sugar transport
l Broad Substrate Utilization Range Non spore forming
l GRAS Status Non-conjugative
Amenable to scale-up
Availability of "industrial"strains
Compatibility with SSF
Cellulase producer
Thermotolerance
High shear tolerance
Available gene transfer system
Promising Biocatalysts
l Zymomonas
l Recombinant Saccharomyces
l Recombinant E. coli
l Lactobacillus
l Xylose-Assimilating Yeasts
l Clostridium
Highlights of Zymomonas mobilis
• Advantages:
– Natural fermentative microorganism (GRAS)
– Near theoretical ethanol yield from glucose
– Reduced yield loss to biomass formation
– No oxygen requirement
– Tolerant to inhibitors in hydrolysates
– High ethanol tolerance
– Fermentation at low pH
– Grows at high sugar concentrations
– High specific productivity
• Limitations
– Narrow substrate utilization range
Pathways Required for Pentose Fermentation
Pentose Metabolism Pathway Entner-Doudoroff Pathway
D-Xylose L-Arabinose D- Glucose
L -a r a b i n o s e i s o m e r a s e
ATP
Xylose Isomerase
L-Ribulose ADP
L -r i b u l o k i n a s e Glucose -6 - P
D - Xylulose ATP
ADP G l u c o n o l a c t o n e -6 - P
Xylulokinase L - R i b u l o s e -5 - P
ATP 6 -P- G l u c o n a t e
L -ribulose-5 - P 4 -e p i m e r a s e
ADP
D - Xylulose-5 - P Ribose-5 - P 2 - Keto -3 - de o x y -6 -P - Gluconate
R i b u l o s e -5 - P
G l y c e r a l d e h y d e -3 - P
Transketolase
1,3 -P- Glycerate
S e d o h e p t u l o s e -7 - P G l y c e r a l d e h y d e -3 - P
ADP
ATP
Transaldolase 3 -P- Glycerate
2 -P- Glycerate
Erythrose -4 - P F r u c t o s e-6 - P
ADP ATP
F r u c t o s e-6 - P Phosphoenolpyruvate Pyruvate
Transketolase G l y c e r a l d e h y d e -3 - P Acetaldehyde + CO2
Ethanol
Cloning Strategy for Pentose
Metabolism Pathway
Xylose Assimilation Genes Arabinose Assimilation Genes Pentose Metabolism Genes
Z. mobilis genome E. coli genome Z. mobilis genome E. coli genome Z. mobilis genome E. coli genome
PCR Synthesis Subcloning PCR Synthesis PCR Synthesis
X h o I/ NotI XhoI SalI NotI BglII XbaI XbaI BglII
Pg a p Px y l Pg a p araB’ araB araA araD Pe n o tal tktA
xylA xylB
PCR-mediated overlap extension a n d Subcloning
NotI BglII BglII
NotI
Pg a p Pg a p araB araA araD Pe n o tal tktA
xylA xylB
P g a p - xylA/ xylB Operon Pg a p - a r a B A D O p e r o n P e n o -tal/tktA O p e r o n
Subcloning
Plasmid Containing Xylose- and
Arabinose-Fermenting Genes
NotI
Peno EcoRV
AvaI
Pgap
EcoRI tal araB
tkt araA
araD
AvaI pZB301 Pgap NotI
19.12 kb xylA
Z. DNA
xylB
r AvaI
Tc
E.coli ori
AvaI
EcoRV
EcoRV AvaI
NotI
Fermentation Profile by Z. mobilis 206C/pZB301
grown on Glu:Xyl:Ara (30:30:20 g/l)
at pH = 5.5, T = 31.5°C
40
Concentration (g/l)
glucose
xylose
arabinose
30
ethanol
20
10
0
0 20 40 60 80 100 120
Time (h)
Specific Aims
1. Develop new genetic engineering tools for the control of gene
dosage and expression, and construct improved strains of Z.
mobilis for efficient ethanol fermentation.
2. Measure intracellular activity through enzymatic assays,
HPLC and NMR spectroscopy and evaluate ethanol production
by the new strains on mixed sugars.
3. Develop a structured kinetic model for the integrated
pathway network and identify potential improvements
through dynamic simulations.
Strategy to Develop More Stable
rZymomonas Strains
ü Develop integration systems.
ü Integrate xylose assimilation genes (xylA, xylB)
pentose-phosphate pathway genes (tal, tkt)
into the Zymomonas genome.
ü Integrate xylose assimilation genes (xylA, xylB)
arabinose assimilation genes (araA, araB, araD)
pentose-phosphate pathway genes (tal,tkt)
into the Zymomonas genome.
Strategy for Gene Integration
Gene Integration by Transposon Homologous Recombination
Transposable Donor
Tc r
element
Circular or linear
Target Z.m. DNA Plasmid DNA
Z.m. Chromosomal DNA
Insertion
Z.m. Chromosomal DNA
Homologous recombination
Tc r
Repair synthesis
loss of donor Site specific recombination
Gene inactivation
Random insertion
Large DNA fragment
Comparison of fermentation performance of plasmid-
bearing and integrated Z. mobilis strains on mixed sugars
(G:40, X:40, A:20 g/l) at pH=5.5, T=30 o C
50 50
206C(pZB301) AX101
40 40
Concentration (g/L)
Concentration (g/L)
Gluc.
30 Xyl. 30
Ara.
20 EtOH
20
10
10
0
0
0 20 40 60 80 100 120
0 20 40 60 80 100 120
Time (hrs)
Time (hrs)
Process yield on mixed sugars
(G:40, X:40, A:20 g/l) at pH=5.5, T=30 o C
100
Process yield (%)
80
206C(pZB301)
60
AX101
AX1
40 G8
20
0
0 20 40 60 80 100 120
Time (hrs)
Stability Test
Ara+ Xyl+
strains Medium
containing
Inoculated
glucose
only
Generation 0 40 80 120 160
Fermentation
in flasks
containing
glucose
+
xylose
+
arabinose
Xylose Utilization
100
Xylose Utilization (%)
90
80
70
60
Gen (0)
50 Gen (40)
Gen (80)
40 Gen (120)
Gen (160)
30
20
10
0
AX1 AX23 AX101 G8
Arabinose Utilization
100
Arabinose Utilization (%)
90
80
70
Gen (0)
60 Gen (40)
Gen (80)
Gen (120)
50
Gen (160)
40
30
20
10
0
AX1 AX23 AX101 G8
Progress along Specific Aim 1
• Integrated the seven genes necessary for xylose and
arabinose fermentation into the Zymomonas mobilis
genome and coordinately expressed the seven genes.
• The chromosomal integrated strains demonstrated
similar ethanol process yield (83%) to the plasmid-
bearing strain from a mixture of glucose, xylose and
arabinose.
• The strains demonstrated stability for 160 generations
on non-selective medium (in the absence of Tc).